A man's track record means nothing to the feminine.
A man could be perfect for ten years, but if he's an asshole for 30 seconds his woman acts like he's always been one.
The feminine responds to the moment of energy, forgetting her man's history of past behavior. A man's past behavior is irrelevant to his woman's feeling in the moment.
But men base much on another man's history of behavior, so they think their own track record should count for something. But to a woman, it doesn't.